New Rule: Robots leaving the arena simultaneously

A discussion forum for proposed changes to the AWS rules

Moderators: administrator, BeligerAnt, petec

Locked
User avatar
BeligerAnt
Posts: 2464
Joined: Wed May 15, 2002 12:00 am
Location: Brighton
Contact:

New Rule: Robots leaving the arena simultaneously

Post by BeligerAnt » Fri Nov 18, 2011 9:23 pm

5j. If opposing robots have left the arena simultaneously (e.g. because they struck each other so hard that they flew apart) then the following will occur

i. The battle will be paused

ii. The robots will be placed straight back into the arena, in their former starting positions, without repairs.

iii. The battle will be restarted
(Note rule 5j was not quoted at the start of the original debate, it is included here for reference)
Simon_Windisch wrote:Insert a rule between 5i and 5j to explain how we decide which robot wins when both leave the arena at very nearly the same time, perhaps it should say (a) the first robot to leave the vertical plane described by the edge of the arena (b) the first robot to contact the floor of the ditch or (c) the first robot to contact the battlebox
Joey wrote:Options (3, b) and (3, c) in my opinion are quite subject to how wide the ditch is as described in 2, heh...(3, a) would be fairest but requires a wide ditch which a lot of arenas don't have, so it probably requires more debate. We do need an unambiguous, standard way of saying when a robot is out of the arena where it's not obvious and I can't think of a decent solution unfortunately :(
Andrew_Hibberd wrote:This is always a tough choice, but I would say floor of the ditch, or battlebox the other side of the pit. However there are casses where it could go to a judges dicision or joint roboteers agreement.
BeligerAnt wrote:Rule 4b is quite clear "A robot that falls off the arena has lost". A robot does not need to have hit the floor of the ditch or the wall of the battlebox to have left the arena. I'm not sure we really need "the first robot to leave the vertical plane described by the edge of the arena" - does this really make the rules simpler??? By having a 150mm wide ditch all robots can cleanly leave the arena and then the only criteria is whether the robot is on the arena or off of it.
Most importantly, we need to allocate judges to watch the fight carefully from different angles. If they cannot call the fight, it has to be restarted (existing rule 5j).
razerdave wrote:I say 'If the victor is indistiguishable by the judges, the robots shall fight again.'
Gary, Team BeligerAnt

User avatar
Simon Windisch
Posts: 2194
Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2003 12:00 am
Location: Reading
Contact:

Re: New Rule: Robots leaving the arena simultaneously

Post by Simon Windisch » Fri Nov 18, 2011 10:18 pm

Yes, so a judges decision here, and no need for an extra rule.

Remote-Controlled Dave
Posts: 3716
Joined: Sun Apr 03, 2005 5:30 pm
Location: Antrim, Northern Ireland
Contact:

Re: New Rule: Robots leaving the arena simultaneously

Post by Remote-Controlled Dave » Sat Nov 19, 2011 7:59 pm

Agreed
Die Gracefully Robotics
Winner - AWS 39

User avatar
petec
Posts: 1042
Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2002 12:00 am
Location: Burgess Hill, West Sussex
Contact:

Re: New Rule: Robots leaving the arena simultaneously

Post by petec » Mon Nov 21, 2011 9:27 pm

Agreed - no change. I've sat with the video of some fights after the event and slowed them down to individual frames and STILL not been able to tell who flew out first. It's tough and the only fair thing is to start again.
------------
RobotWars101.org
RobotWars101.co.uk
Antweights.com
Antweights.co.uk
AntweightWorldSeries.com

Locked